U.S. Secretary of Defense Wants to Move Past GPS to MEMS-Based Navigation, PNT Experts Doubtful

July 9, 2015

Written by Editor

By Dee Ann Divis

Ashton Carter, the new U.S. Secretary of Defense has been making clear he supports moving past GPS to a disbursed network based on microelectromechanical systems or MEMS for position, navigation, and timing (PNT) information.

Carter, who was tapped to lead the Pentagon in February, appears to have first publicly floated the idea a year ago, about six months after leaving the Department of Defense (DoD), where he had served most recently as deputy secretary of defense, a role that included cochairing the interdepartmental National Space-Based PNT Executive Committee.

“I hate GPS,” Carter said during a wide-ranging conversation about innovation in June 2014. “The idea that we are all hooked to a satellite — formerly bought by me to my great resentment — in a semi-synchronous orbit that that doesn’t work in certain circumstances, does not work indoors or in valleys in Afghanistan, is ridiculous.” His reference to buying GPS satellites refers to a previous stint (April 2009–October 2011) as undersecretary of defense for acquisition, technology, and logistics.

Speaking on the podcast a16z, which is supported by the Silicon Valley venture capital firm Andreessen Horowitz, Carter said he thought the constellation’s future was limited, and that in a couple of decades PNT information would be obtainable from highly capable computer chips installed in products to support the Internet of Things. The resulting network, he said, would be more resistant to jamming and disruption.

[big_button url=”https://insidegnss.com/u-s-secretary-of-defense-wants-to-move-past-gps-to-mems-based-navigation-pnt-experts-doubtful/”]Read More[/big_button]

What Can YOU Do? How Can YOU Help?

PNT is the quiet backbone of everything but too many leaders still don’t see the risk.

But you do. You understand the systems, the dependencies, the failure chains. That insight is rare — and it’s exactly what your country needs right now. Contact your government leaders and industry decision-makers and tell them resilient PNT isn’t a feature — it’s the foundation everything else depends on.

Start the Conversation

Use our Resilient PNT Key Talking Points to make the case.

U.S. Advocates

Find your representatives at Congress.gov, then use our email template to reach them in minutes.

When you get a response, let us know. Every conversation strengthens the mission.

More PNT News

US Congress hearing on PNT –  June 4th

US Congress hearing on PNT – June 4th

Image credit: House Energy and Commerce Committee What's new: A congressional hearing titled Where Are We?: Examining Positioning, Navigation, and Timing Capabilities in the United States. Why it's important:  The hearing is being held by the Communications and...

GPS NOTAMS Not Enough for Safety – Jeremy Bennington at Spirent

GPS NOTAMS Not Enough for Safety – Jeremy Bennington at Spirent

Image: Jeremy Bennington What's new: An important opinion piece on LinkedIn by RNTF member Jeremy Bennington at Spirent about intentional GPS disruption and aviation safety. Why it's important: People's lives are at stake. False contacts, bad locations, relying on...

UK Defence Minister’s Aircraft Jammed… Again – BBC

UK Defence Minister’s Aircraft Jammed… Again – BBC

Image: GPSJam.org - Jamming in the Baltic the day of the minister's flight What's new: The aircraft carrying another high ranking official experienced jamming in northern Europe. Why it's important: Even though jamming impacts tens of thousands of ordinary people on...

UK maritime navigation leader on chokepoints – PoliticsHome

UK maritime navigation leader on chokepoints – PoliticsHome

Image: UK General Lighthouse Authority - 28 days of ship traffic in Dover Strait What's new: An opinion piece from the head of the UK's General Lighthouse Authority which is responsible for maritime aids to navigation and assists government in marine spatial planning....

Get PNT News in Your Inbox